Château Ausone 2000 in New York, Between Casa Cipriani and Vinitaly USA

Bottiglia di Château Ausone 2000 a Casa Cipriani, New York

New York at night: a city that never decided what to be

I like to arrive at a great bottle on foot. It is a small superstition of mine, like a priest who walks to Mass: the legs must earn what the palate is about to receive.

So I walked. New York at night is the only city I know that has never decided what it wants to be when it grows up. A cast-iron warehouse leans against a glass tower, which leans against a tenement with a fire escape like a zipper, which leans against a church that looks embarrassed to be there. Nobody planned this. It happened, the way a conversation happens at a long dinner.

And then, every few blocks, the 1930s step out of the dark. The Art Deco towers, with their stepped crowns, their bronze doors, their eagles and sunbursts and geometric optimism. The irony is perfect, and very New York: the most confident buildings in the city were finished when almost nobody had a job. The Depression built cathedrals to a future it could not afford. Maybe this is the first lesson of the evening. Beauty is often a loan taken against hope.

Between the cathedrals, the city does not bother with makeup. Some blocks are sketchy, honestly sketchy, the kind where you walk a little faster and pretend you are checking your phone. Steam from the street, a shuttered laundromat, a man explaining something important to a parking meter. New York does not hide its kitchen from the dining room. I find this very honest, and very Italian.

A bottle of water on the Lower East Side

On the Lower East Side I stopped for water. This is the neighbourhood of the great Jewish migration, of pushcarts and synagogues and grandmothers who knew exactly how much a herring should cost. I passed a mosque, lit and quiet. A few steps later I entered a mini market run by a Latino family, with a radio playing bachata and a cat sleeping on the lottery tickets.

So: a Jewish neighbourhood, a mosque on the corner, Latinos at the till, and an Italian buying water before drinking a French wine. If you wrote this in a novel, your editor would cut it as too symbolic.

Spike Lee put this kind of block on screen in Do the Right Thing: the Italian pizzeria, the Korean grocery, the Black and Puerto Rican neighbours, everybody sharing one hot street. He did not pretend it was paradise. The heat rises, the music gets louder, and things break. But what stayed with me from that film is not the explosion. Instead, it is the daily miracle that comes before it, the thousand small negotiations that let people who should not, on paper, get along, get along.

The man at the counter gave me my change and said, “Have a good night, papi.” I was, for one second, everybody’s father. I paid $2.50 for the water. Keep that number in mind.

Casa Cipriani: the ship that never sails

Then the water, and the end of the island. At 10 South Street stands the Battery Maritime Building, a Beaux-Arts ferry terminal designed in 1906 and finished three years later. For decades it sent commuters across the East River to Brooklyn: clerks, dockers, mothers with shopping bags. Its green iron and herringbone tile still glow at night like an old opera house that forgot to close.

Today it is Casa Cipriani. The interiors are by Thierry Despont, the designer who restored the Statue of Liberty. He imagined the place as a great ocean liner of the 1930s, moored forever over the harbour. Inside: lacquered mahogany so polished you can read your conscience in it, columns of white light, black-and-white photographs, small lamps on every table, and on the floor a great compass of marble, its numbers pointing nowhere and everywhere.

It is a ship that never leaves port. I find this the most elegant idea in the world, and also the most New York one. You can feel the crossing without the seasickness, the voyage without the departure.

The passengers, I must say, were very young and very well. Beautiful jackets, beautiful teeth, the calm of people for whom the bill is a formality. A ferry terminal once built for clerks now welcomes the grandchildren of the people who employed them. The building has not moved. The tide has.

Château Ausone 2000: a poet, a river and a price

With a long-time friend and a table of serious collectors, we opened a Château Ausone 2000. Some wines have a vintage. Ausone has a genealogy.

An Italian in New York, drinking French wine

I should add a small detail, the kind that would get me expelled from any self-respecting consortium. I am in New York for the New York edition of Vinitaly USA, to talk about Italian wine. Friuli, to be precise: the region of the Alps and the Adriatic, of Friulano and Ribolla, and one of the rainiest corners of Italy, so let’s call it the region with the most water, which will matter at the end of this story. And where am I sitting? In an Italian restaurant, born from the Venetian family of Harry’s Bar, a short drive from the Friulian hills. And what am I drinking? A French wine.

An Italian, in an Italian house, in New York for Italian wine, with a glass of Bordeaux. My friends at Vinitaly USA will forgive me, I hope, because this too is research. To tell the story of your own wines abroad, you must first taste what the world measures them against. Ausone is a ruler, and Friuli does not fear rulers. Tomorrow, I promise, Ribolla.

Vinitaly USA, in its third edition and its first in New York, brought some 300 Italian exhibitors and 2,500 wines to Pier 36, on the East River. Italian wine is already the most loved in New York after California’s, and Veronafiere came to remind the city why. Notice the geography: Cipriani was born in Venice, on the lagoon; Vinitaly pitched its tents on a pier; Casa Cipriani is moored on the same river, at the tip of the harbour; and Ausone looks down on the Dordogne, on the other side of the ocean. Everybody in this story lives on the water. Nobody, apparently, drinks it.

The history behind Château Ausone 2000

But back to the bottle. The château takes its name from Ausonius, the Roman poet and consul of the 4th century who kept vines on this hill above Saint-Émilion. He is remembered above all for Mosella, a long poem in love with a river. Sixteen centuries later we were drinking his hill above another river, inside a building made for crossing it. Ausonius would have approved. After all, poets like a coincidence more than a contract.

The cellars of Ausone are carved into the limestone on which Bordeaux was built. The wine never leaves the rock, and yet it travels. Same as the ship: a voyage without departure. The 2000, the vintage Alain Vauthier called his dream, is still young, still a little proud, with graphite and violets and what I can only call a Roman patience. It has the tannins of a senator who knows the debate will be long.

What a bottle of Château Ausone 2000 costs

Now the numbers, because wine is also arithmetic. In the spring of 2001 the château released this 2000 to the Bordeaux trade at €195 a bottle, a price the newspapers called a record. Today the same bottle trades at around €1,000 in Europe, and in London’s grand stores closer to £1,800. Twenty-five years of patience, multiplied by five. Meanwhile, my bottle of water cost $2.50. The arithmetic of the evening is not complicated, only uncomfortable.

Two Europes

Here I must confess something. Between the lamb chops and the second glass, my phone showed me home. In Florence, in Milan, in Lyon, in Brussels, in Madrid, people were in the streets this month, protesting high prices, low salaries and the cost of simply living. Teachers, students, transport workers, pensioners. Not asking for Ausone. Asking for rent.

And there I was, an Italian on a ship that never sails, drinking the most patient wine of the Right Bank. I felt the distance between two Europes: the one in the glass and the one in the piazza. I did not feel guilty, exactly. Guilt is a little too comfortable, a way of paying the bill twice and feeling elegant about it. Instead, I felt something more useful: a slight vertigo.

The stories behind great wines

The funny thing, or the honest thing, is that this is my job. I am paid to taste these bottles so I can tell their story to the many people who will never open one. A strange profession: a kind of ambassador for a country most people will only visit through words. I try to do it the way my mentors did, with curiosity rather than reverence, and with the conviction that a story about a great wine is also a story about the farmers, the stone, the weather and the work behind it. The price is the least interesting thing about Ausone. Nevertheless, it is not nothing, and it would be dishonest to pretend otherwise.

The same water: from Saint-Émilion to Friuli

What can I say? I love this city. After all these years I still cannot explain how its contrasts manage to coexist: the deco cathedral and the sketchy block, the synagogue street and the mosque and the bachata, the $2.50 water and the €1,000 wine, all within a walk of forty minutes. Other cities separate their worlds with motorways and postcodes. New York, instead, puts them in the same elevator and says: work it out.

Maybe that is why I feel at home here. I like my job, I like to work hard, and New York has exactly the rhythm I need, a tempo slightly too fast, like a waltz played by a jazz band. It always triggers in me a reflection on society, on human beings, on how we all live together on this small, crowded, improbable biosphere.

One river, many different prices

On the way out I looked at the river, black and shining under the bridge. And I thought: the water of this planet is always the same water. It goes up into clouds, down into rivers, into the sea, into a vine root, into a glass. Some of the water Ausonius drank on the other side of the ocean, sixteen centuries ago, is probably flowing under the Brooklyn Bridge tonight. Some of it is in the mini market fridge. Another part, transformed by limestone and patience, was in my glass. And some of it is falling right now as rain on the hills of Friuli, waiting to become next year’s Ribolla.

We all drink from the same river. We just pay very different prices for the glass.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *